MitraMSI > Motherboard > Three Motherboards AMD 890GX Compared

Three Motherboards AMD 890GX Compared


8 May 2010. Author: mas_sas

AMD’s chipsets have long provided great features for the money, especially compared to high-end platforms like X48 and X58 from its chief rival, Intel. Everything between the mid-priced (still high-end) 790FX to its more commonplace integrated-graphics products can be attractive, depending on your usage model.

The entire range provides expanded PCIe 2.0 pathways for multi-card configurations, and its integrated-graphics parts actually deliver reasonable 3D performance and an option for multi-monitor support. If you love building productivity-oriented machines at an affordable price or need the ultimate in configurability, AMD might be your best choice. After all, we've yet to be bowled over by Intel's CPU efforts between $100 and $200, while AMD continues to offer a number of compelling quad-core models.

 

alt

 

Today’s launch focuses on two components, the 890GX northbridge with its revised Radeon HD 4290 graphics engine and the SB850 southbridge. Upgrades include DX10.1 graphics, SATA 6Gb/s, two additional USB 2.0 ports, and integrated gigabit networking.

But our emphasis here is on a trio of motherboards emerging alongside the new core logic from Asus, Gigabyte, and MSI. Note that you'll see USB 3.0 support in the pages to come. However, the 890GX platform does not natively support USB 3.0; rather, it's added via an on-board controller.

But our emphasis here is on a trio of motherboards emerging alongside the new core logic from Asus, Gigabyte, and MSI. Note that you'll see USB 3.0 support in the pages to come. However, the 890GX platform does not natively support USB 3.0; rather, it's added via an on-board controller.

Motherboard Features

AMD’s multi-monitor advantage comes from the way it separates PCIe and GPU functions to deliver sixteen PCIe 2.0 lanes to graphics cards (up to two) without sacrificing integrated graphics functionality. Its Catalyst driver package controls both onboard and discrete Radeon graphics controllers simultaneously, seamlessly managing multiple desktop configurations. The three boards in today’s roundup have another advantage over those of our recent H55 comparison, in that those products didn’t support DVI dual-link mode for extra-large displays.

890GX Motherboard Features
  Asus M4A89GTD
Pro/USB3
Gigabyte
890GPA-UD3H
MSI
890GXM-G65
PCB Revision 1.01G 1.0 1.0
Chipset AMD 890GX/SB850 AMD 890GX/SB850 AMD 890GX/SB850
Voltage Regulator Ten Phases Five Phases Five Phases
BIOS 0402 (02/09/2010) F3 (02/08/2010) V1.0B18 (02/22/2010)
200.0 MHz BCLK 200.7 MHz (+0.35%) 200.0 MHz (+0.0 MHz) 200.0 MHz (+0.0 MHz)
Clock Generator ICS 9LPRS477CKL Realtek RTM880N-793 Realtek RTM880N-793
Sideport DRAM H5TQ1G63BFR-12C
128MB DDR3-1600
H5TQ1G63BFR-12C
128MB DDR3-1600
H5TQ1G63BFR-12C
128MB DDR3-1600
Internal Interfaces
PCIe x16 2 (x16/x0, x8/x8) 2 (x16/x0, x8/x8) 2 (x16/x0, x8/x8)
PCIe x1/x4 1/1 3/0 1/0
Legacy PCI 2 2 1
USB 2.0 4 (8-ports) 4 (8-ports) 4 (8-ports)
IEEE-1394 1 2 None
Serial Port 1 1 1
Parallel Port None None 1
Floppy No Yes No
Ultra-ATA 133 1 (2-drives) 1 (2-drives) 1 (2-drives)
SATA 3.0 Gb/s None None None
SATA 6.0 Gb/s 6 6 5
4-Pin Fan 2 2 1
3-Pin Fan 2 2 1
FP-Audio Yes Yes Yes
CD-Audio No Yes Yes
S/PDIF I/O Output Only Both Output Only
Power Button No No No
Reset Button No No No
CLR_CMOS Button Jumper Only Jumper Only Jumper Only
Diagnostics Panel Pass/Fail LEDs Pass/Fail LEDs Pass/Fail LEDs
I/O Panel Connectors
P/S 2 1 1 1
USB 2.0 4 4 4
USB 3.0 2 2 2
IEEE-1394 1 1 None
Network Single Single Single
eSATA 1 None 1
CLR_CMOS Button No No No
Digital Audio Out Optical Optical Optical
Digital Audio In None None None
Analog Audio 6 6 6
Video Outputs DVI, HDMI, VGA DVI, HDMI, VGA DVI, HDMI, VGA
DVI Dual Link Yes Unverified Yes
Dual Monitor Yes Yes Yes
Mass Storage Controllers
Chipset SATA 6x SATA 6Gb/s 6x SATA 6Gb/s 6x SATA 6Gb/s
Chipset RAID Modes 0, 1, 5, 10 0, 1, 5, 10 0, 1, 5, 10
Add-In SATA JMB361 PCIe
1x eSATA 3.0 Gb/s
JMB363 PCIe
1x eSATA 3.0 Gb/s
None
Add-In Ultra ATA JMB361 PCIe JMB363 PCIe JMB368 PCIe
USB 3.0 NEC D720200F1 NEC D720200F1 NEC D720200F1
IEEE-1394 VT6308P PCI
2x 400 Mb/s
TSB43AB23 PCI
3x 400 Mb/s
None
Gigabit Ethernet
Primary LAN RTL8111E PCIe RTL8111D PCIe RTL8111DL PCIe
Secondary LAN None None None
Audio
HD Audio Codec ALC892 ALC892 ALC889
DDL/DTS Connect Unspecified Dolby Digital Live Unspecified


Unfortunately, while Gigabyte’s dual-link mode appeared to accommodate our lab's 2560x1600 display, loading the driver seemed to break this feature. This is most likely a driver bug, since AMD’s Catalyst 10.3 Preview package is not yet finished.

Another advantage today’s motherboards have over the Intel H55-based competition is the chipset’s additional PCIe 2.0 lanes, one of which supplies each of today’s motherboards with the same USB 3.0 controller at its full 5.0 Gb/s interface bandwidth. Intel’s chipset lanes run at half-speed, so that two lanes and a costly PCIe switch are required to reach the controller’s maximum throughput.

Asus M4A89GTD Pro/USB3

Asus’ full-sized board provides the extra space needed to access most 890GX chipset functions, including two of the chipset’s six PCI slots and five of its eight PCIe 2.0 lanes. Much of the chipset’s remaining connectivity is tied to on-board controllers.

alt

Only four of the chipset’s USB 2.0 ports are found on the I/O panel, as the area is far too laden with other connections to allow for more. Two USB 3.0, FireWire, eSATA, digital and analog audio, gigabit networking, and triple-format display output round out the rear.

Builders looking for the best performance from a single card need to pay close attention to the included VGA switch card, which is used to control the number of lanes fed to the dark-blue slot. Sixteen lanes are shared across two graphics card slots in x8 mode, but placing the card into the light-blue slot redirects its eight lanes to the dark-blue slot for full x16 connectivity to a single card. This low-cost switching method eliminates the need for more expensive devices, such as the electronic switches used by its competitors.

alt

Four USB 2.0 headers support up to eight front-panel ports or devices, but the add-in ATA controller supports only Ultra ATA drives. All ATA connectors including the chipset’s six SATA 6Gb/s ports are found near the bottom edge, which could make cable installation difficult for the top-bay drives in mid-tower cases.

Front-panel audio is found in its usual bottom-rear-corner position, where it will usually be difficult to reach with the cables of top-bay connections.

BIOS

Reference Clock 100-600 MHz (1 MHz)
CPU Multiplier Yes
iGFX Clock 400-1500 MHz (1 MHz)
DRAM Data Rates REF x4-x8 (x1.33)
PCIe Clock 100-150 MHz (1 MHz)
CPU Vcore 0.65-2.05V (3.125mV)
IMC Voltage 0.4-1.8V (3.125mV)
890GX Voltage 0.8-2.0V (6.25mV)
SB850 Voltage 1.10-1.40V (50mV)
DRAM Voltage 1.20-2.50V (6.25mV)
CAS Latency 4-12 Cycles
tRCD 4-12 Cycles
tRP 5-12 Cycles
tRAS 15-30 Cycles


The M4A89GTD Pro/USB3 provides a fairly long list of overclocking controls, supporting even sideport memory overclocks (DDR3-1333 to DDR3-2000) and over-voltage (from 1.50 to 1.80 volts).

altaltZoom altaltZoom

A fairly short selection of DRAM timings still provides all the settings most tuners will need.

altaltZoom altaltZoom

Asus is proud of its Core Unlocker feature, which is meant to enable the disabled cores of Phenom II X2 and X3 processors. This is notable since the SB850 southbridge does not include ACC as a built-in feature. Nevertheless, while we've had minor luck randomly unlocking a handful of retail-purchased CPUs, we wouldn't recommend you buy a cheaper processor hoping for an unlock when you really want the higher-end CPU. It's not like we're dealing with the difference between a Core i5-750 and a Core i7-975 Extreme or anything, cost-wise.

altaltZoom

Up to eight BIOS configurations can be saved as user profiles or exported to a drive.

Accessories

Asus includes four SATA cables with its M4A89GTD Pro/USB3, but only two are marked as SATA 6 Gb/s capable.

Gigabyte GA-890GPA-UD3H

Gigabyte’s first entry into the 890GX world comes with a few extra features compared to chief-rival Asus, with a full seven expansion slots, automatic PCIe x16 to dual x8 slot switching, and an added SATA connection.

alt

Except for its missing eSATA port, the 890GPA-UD3H I/O panel could have been lifted directly from the Asus board. Gigabyte seems to be of the opinion that most eSATA users would rather connect their devices via the front panel ports of select cases, placing both additional connections internally. Two USB 3.0 ports highlight the I/O panel’s added features.

alt

A row of pathway switches behind the top x16-length slot mean that Gigabyte's customers won't need to mess with pathway switch cards, and can simply insert a second graphics card or remove it at will (though this does add to cost). Like Asus, Gigabyte provides what would have previously been noticed as an exceptional number of internal USB 2.0 ports to support up to eight devices, and goes one step farther by adding a second internal FireWire connection.

Windows XP users who would like to take full advantage of the chipset’s AHCI or RAID capabilities will appreciate Gigabyte’s retention of a floppy interface, though putting it under the lowest PCI slot does make access inconvenient. On the other hand, SATA and Ultra ATA connectors are ideally positioned near the center of the motherboard’s front edge, for easy access to both upper and lower drive bays.

Gigabyte has, for a long time, put its front-panel audio connector near the center of the motherboard’s rear edge for easier access from above, though some users who’s cables would have been long enough to reach the bottom have mentioned that it makes the cable harder to hide.

BIOS

Reference Clock 200-500 MHz (1MHz)
CPU Multiplier Yes
iGFX Clock 200-2000 MHz (1 MHz)
DRAM Data Rates REF x4-x8 (x1.33)
PCIe Clock 100-150 MHz (1MHz)
CPU Vcore -0.6 to +0.6V (25mV)
IMC Voltage -0.6 to +0.6V (25mV)
890GX Voltage 0.90-1.60V (20mV)
SB850 Voltage Not Adjustable
DRAM Voltage 1.28-2.45V (15mV)
CAS Latency 3-11 Cycles
tRCD 3-15 Cycles
tRP 3-15 Cycles
tRAS 3-31 Cycles


Overclockers will love the variety of configurable settings provided in Gigabyte’s GA-890GPA-UD3H BIOS. We prefer to see actual (rather than offset) voltage listed, but Gigabyte makes it easy to see “where you’re going” by also listing the expected result.

altaltZoom altaltZoom

Memory timing selections are only mildly advanced beyond the basic overclocker’s needs, but do include drive-strength control.

altaltZoom

Eight custom BIOS configurations can be saved in a protected area of the BIOS IC as user profiles.

altaltZoom altaltZoom

Users who forget to save a user profile in BIOS can still retrieve previous settings, since the motherboard automatically retains the “last known good” configuration.

Accessories

We were disappointed to find only two SATA cables in Gigabyte’s installation kit, though retail samples might contain more.

 

MSI 890GXM-G65

MSI was the only company to provide a microATX board for AMD’s chipset launch, though this particular form factor is the most likely place to find an upper-range integrated-graphics chipset. Its 890GXM-G65 still provides most of the features of the full-sized Asus rival, minus an eSATA controller and two expansion slots.

altaltZoom

The rear panel does contain a single eSATA connection, improved to the 6Gb/s standard because it uses the chipset’s integrated controller. Like its rivals, the 890GXM-G65 also provides two USB 3.0 ports.

We think it’s a little humorous that all three motherboards provide HDMI display output, but not DisplayPort, since this AMD-backed interface is found on so many Intel-based motherboards. Yet, this particular board will likely find its way into many home-theater systems, where HDMI is the most common HDCP-compliant standard.

altaltZoom

The 890GXM-G65 actually looks like a compact game system motherboard with its short and fat heat pipe cooler, dual PCIe x16-length slots and electronic pathway switches for dual x8 or single x16 slot modes, and many among the AMD faithful will certainly see fit to use it as such. Game performance is an area where AMD processors remain competitive, though the chipset’s Radeon HD 4290 integrated graphics will likely be of little use to value-seeking gamers.

The 890GXM-G65 lacks the FireWire controller builders rely on to activate the often-unused front panel connection of most media-center cases. Its forward-facing SATA ports are likewise unsuited for many of those cases, since the motherboard’s front edge will often be blocked by drive bays. On the other hand, compact game system builders will often find its outward-facing SATA port blocked by the heatsink of large graphics cards, so it appears that MSI’s only solution would have been to eliminate the Ultra ATA connector and try to place its SATA ports there.

Like Asus, MSI positions its front-panel audio connector in the motherboard’s bottom rear corner. MSI moved it slightly forward, however, and we’ve encountered many builds where the extra inch solves cable installation woes.

BIOS

Reference Clock 190-690 MHz (1 MHz)
CPU Multiplier Yes
iGFX Clock 150-1500 MHz (1 MHz)
DRAM Data Rates REF x4-x8 (x1.33)
PCIe Clock 90-190 MHz (1MHz)
CPU Vcore 1.02-1.97V (10mV)
IMC Voltage 0.39-1.46V (1mV)
890GX Voltage 1.05-21.65V (6.25mV)
SB850 Voltage 0.89-1.40V (5.3mV)
DRAM Voltage 0.97-2.45V (~8mV)
CAS Latency 4-12 Cycles
tRCD 5-12 Cycles
tRP 5-12 Cycles
tRAS 15-30 Cycles


MSI applied full-sized overclocking features to its microATX 890GXM-G65, making it easy to extract peak performance from a portable gaming system. Underclocking is also possible, allowing reduced-noise cooling for “silent” PCs and media centers.

altaltZoom altaltZoom

The 890GXM-G65 has a relatively broad selection of memory timings, which can be configured separately per-channel. MSI adds several drive-strength controls for enhanced stability when operating memory beyond its intended parameters.

altaltZoom altaltZoom altaltZoom

Accessories

The 890GXM-G65 we received included an incomplete cable kit that doesn’t support an SATA hard drive and optical drive simultaneously. While many builders have cables to spare, those who don’t should take a second look at production samples to see if the package has been tweaked.

Test Settings

Test System Configuration
CPU AMD Phenom X4 955 Black Edition
3.20 GHz, 6.0 MB Cache
RAM Kingston KHX2133C9D3T1K2/4GX (4GB)
DDR3-2133 at DDR3-1333 CAS 7-7-7-20
Integrated Graphics Radeon HD 4290 at default settings
128MB Sideport RAM, Automatic shared RAM allocation
Discrete Graphics Sapphire Radeon HD 5850 1GB
725 MHz GPU, GDDR5-4000
System Hard Drive Western Digital Velociraptor WD3000HLFS, 300GB
10,000 RPM, SATA 3Gb/s, 16 MB cache
Empty Hard Drive Crucial RealSSD C300 256GB SATA 6Gb/s
Sound Integrated HD Audio
Network Integrated Gigabit Networking
Power Corsair CMPSU-850HX 850W Modular
ATX12V v2.2, EPS12V, 80-Plus Gold
Software
OS Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate x64
Graphics and Chipset AMD Catalyst 10.3 Preview


Integrated Controller Test
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Campaign, Act III, Second Sun (45 sec. FRAPS)
Test Set 1: Highest Settings, No AA
Test Set 2: Highest Settings, 4x AA
Crysis Patch 1.2.1, DirectX 10, 64-bit executable, benchmark tool
Low Quality, No AA, 1280x720
Dirt 2 Demo In-game benchmark
Ultra Low Quality Preset, No AA, 1280x720
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call Of Pripyat Call Of Pripyat Benchmark version
Minimum Preset, DX10 EFDL, No AA, 1280x720
h2benchw 3.13 Sequential Reads and Writes (KB/s)


With integrated controller tests taken care of, our remaining benchmarks used Sapphire’s Radeon HD 5850 graphics card.

Benchmark Configuration
3D Games
Crysis Patch 1.2.1, DirectX 10, 64-bit executable, benchmark tool
Test Set 1: High Quality, No AA
Test Set 2: Very High Quality, 4x AA
Dirt 2 Demo In-game benchmark
Test Set 1: High Quality Preset, No AA
Test Set 2: Ultra Quality Preset, 4x AA
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Campaign, Act III, Second Sun (45 sec. FRAPS)
Test Set 1: Highest Settings, No AA
Test Set 2: Highest Settings, 4x AA
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call Of Pripyat Call Of Pripyat Benchmark version
Test Set 1: High Preset, DX11 EFDL, No AA
Test Set 2: Ultra Preset, DX11 EFDL, 4x MSAA
Audio/Video Encoding
iTunes Version:9.0.2.25 x64
Audio CD (Terminator II SE), 53 min
Default format AAC
Handbrake 0.9.4 Version 0.9.4, convert first .vob file from The Last Samurai (1.0 GB) to .mp4, High Profile
TMPEGEnc 4.0 XPress Version: 4.7.3.292
Import File: Terminator 2 SE DVD (5 Minutes)
Resolution: 720x576 (PAL) 16:9
DivX Codec 6.9.1 Encoding mode: Insane Quality
Enhanced multithreading enabled using SSE4
Quarter-pixel search
XviD 1.2.2 Display encoding status = off
MainConcept Reference 1.6.1 MPEG2 to MPEG2 (H.264), MainConcept H.264/AVC Codec, 28 sec HDTV 1920x1080 (MPEG2), Audio: MPEG2 (44.1 kHz, 2 Channel, 16-Bit, 224 kbp/s), Mode: PAL (25 FPS)
Productivity
Adobe Photoshop CS4 Version: 11.0 x64, Filter 15.7 MB TIF Image
Radial Blur, Shape Blur, Median, Polar Coordinates
Autodesk 3ds Max 2010 Version: 11.0 x64, Rendering Dragon Image at 1920x1080 (HDTV)
Grisoft AVG Anti-Virus 9.0 Version: 9.0.663, Virus base: 270.14.1/2407, Benchmark: Scan 334 MB Folder of ZIP/RAR compressed files
WinRAR 3.90 Version x64 3.90, Dictionary = 4,096 KB, Benchmark: THG-Workload (334 MB)
7-Zip Version 4.65: Format=Zip, Compression=Ultra, Method=Deflate, Dictionary Size=32KB, Word Size=128, Threads=8
Benchmark: THG-Workload (334 MB)
Synthetic Benchmarks and Settings
3DMark Vantage Version: 1.0.1, GPU and CPU scores
PCMark Vantage Version: 1.0.1.0 x64, System, Productivity, Hard Disk Drive benchmarks
SiSoftware Sandra 2010

Version 2010.1.16.11, CPU Test = CPU Arithmetic / MultiMedia, Memory Test = Bandwidth Benchmark


Benchmark Results: Integrated Graphics And SATA 6Gb/s

AMD claims 3D performance superiority for the integrated Radeon HD 4290 graphics controller of its new 890GX northbridge, but we think it looks amazingly like the 790GX, save for the DirectX 10.1 update. With much of its focus on media centers, we wanted to find out whether it could also support modern games at the common 720p resolution.

alt

alt

Performance between the new Radeon HD 4290 integrated GPU looks remarkably similar to that of its predecessor’s Radeon HD 3300 core. If you can live with film-speed frame rates, you’ll at least find two of these games playable at their lowest settings.

Our original assessment was that AMD’s SB850 southbridge was the biggest news of today’s release, with the only integrated SATA 6Gb/s controller on the market. Let’s see how today’s motherboards compare to the previous generation’s SATA 3Gb/s part.

alt

alt

Though none of the integrated solutions could exceed the former standard’s 300 MB/s limit, all of them outpace the former chipset’s controller. We expect the lower SB850 scores to go up after a few BIOS improvements.

Benchmark Results: Modern Warfare 2 And Crysis

With a graphics card installed, the previous-generation motherboard leads CoD:MW2 slightly.

alt

alt

alt

alt

MSI bursts forward in Crysis, while the legacy motherboard tips towards the bottom.

The elder motherboard edges ahead for the second time in our basic DiRT 2 test, but enhanced quality settings bring MSI’s new part to the top.

alt

alt

alt

alt

The mature motherboard leads overall in the latest S.T.A.L.K.E.R. development, but can’t differentiate itself at high resolutions.

Benchmark Results: Audio And Video Encoding

Apple's iTunes encoder responds almost exclusively to CPU clock speed, so we expect to see little to no performance difference, regardless of chipset.

alt

alt

The older board strangely falls behind in Handbrake, but most users wouldn’t notice a difference this small.

alt

alt

TMPGEnc and MainConcept get no benefit from the new chipset.

Benchmark Results: Productivity

Adobe Photoshop and 3ds Max show no performance variation between motherboards.

alt

alt

alt

alt

AVG gains only one second with Asus’ 890GX solution, while WinRAR and 7-Zip reveal zero performance difference.

Benchmark Results: Synthetic Benchmarks

3DMark Vantage shows Asus in the lead by a few points, but not by more than the normal margin of error. The elder board falls behind by a barely-noticeable amount.

alt

alt

MSI leads in PCMark, but a thorough check through BIOS and with CPU-Z didn’t reveal the source of this difference.

alt

alt

Gigabyte and Asus lead in Sandra’s CPU benchmarks, but differences this small could be coincidental.

alt

The legacy motherboard leads in Sandra Memory Bandwidth by enough to explain its equally-insignificant win in some games.

Conclusion

With an integrated SATA 6Gb/s controller, AMD’s SB850 southbridge is probably the best reason to select an 890GX motherboard over the products it replaces. While neither the new or old interfaces could approach the limits of their technology, H2benchw test showed a 42% bandwidth increase between the best 890GX implementation and the chipset it replaces.

Leaving synthetics out of the equation, the only reason to chose AMD’s latest northbridge over its predecessor is its support for DirectX 10.1 graphics features, compared to the earlier part’s DX10 support. We don’t see that minor improvement as a significant reason to upgrade, and instead refer to our original assessment that SATA 6Gb/s is the only apparent reason to pick the new part over the old.

We say apparent only because AMD has not completely clarified and changes that might be required to support its next processor core. We’d like to believe that old motherboards will find new life with nothing more than a BIOS update, but AMD has not yet provided the additional information. We do know that these three 890GX platforms are slated for what AMD refers to as "planned compatibility" with Phenom II X6, but the jury is out on 790GX.

We expect that next month’s 890GX motherboard prices will be similar to those of last month’s 790GX parts, so buyers should find the SB850’s new SATA controller a bargain. But while true bargain-hunters might also consider seeking out clearance prices on previous-generation motherboard models, some may find that they’ve painted themselves into a corner by doing so. For us the SB850 is a “good enough” reason to chose the 890GX, and the increased likelihood of supporting AMD’s next-generation core seals the deal.

 


Back